View Reviews and Comments

Editors can access all feedback from Reviewers and Editors related to a submission by using the View Reviews and Comments link. The link is available in the submission's Action column, in the left section of the Reviewer Selection Summary page, and at the top of Reviewer search pages.

Click the link to open a pop-up window that displays a chart of information pertaining to Reviewers and Editors for all versions of the submission. The recommendation term for each person displays as a hyperlink. The hyperlink opens the review form or Editor form submitted by the person.

Depending on publication configuration, Reviewers are listed either in the order they accepted review invitations (or were assigned) or when they completed review.

Editors are listed in order of the date invited or assigned to the submission, with most recent at the top. Order does not change based on revision.

Corresponding Author's response to Reviewers (entered in Respond to Reviewers submission step) are also available on this page.

The page also displays a link to the View Review Question Responses page, where Editors can see Reviewer responses to questions.

 

To return to previous page click ALT + left arrow